|
1997 W. Beaty
|
Q1: WHAT IS A "FREE ENERGY DEVICE?"A: The term "Free energy device" has a number of meanings:
For example, when Becquerel discovered that uranium ore would fog film
plates, he had discovered a "free energy" device. When physicists
eventually explained this in terms of the radioactivity of unstable
elements, uranium stopped being "free energy."
So, whenever a successful device is first attained, but before most people
stop their hostile disbelief, and before scientists track down the true
source of the unexplained energy, then the device can be called a "free
energy" machine.
Q2: AREN'T THEY ALL JUST "PERPETUAL MOTION" MACHINES, AND IMPOSSIBLE EVEN IN PRINCIPLE?A: Is a thermoelectric cell a perpetual motion machine? How about a nuclear battery? After all, both of these devices just sit there silently while continually producing energy from no obvious source. But a little investigation of either device will reveal the hidden energy source. If somebody discovers a new process which appears to emit energy continuously, then obviously that process must be extracting energy from somewhere. A true "perpetual motion machine" is impossible, but a machine which taps an unknown energy source is not.
In my experience the main problem which interferes with this research
is "politics." Some scientists are
greatly embarrassed by any important discoveries made by amateurs. They
strongly hope that "free energy" reports indeed are always crackpottery.
Also, overly-zealous skeptics may wish to ridicule all claims of
successful "free energy" devices, and place them into the wastecan labeled
"Perpetual Motion Crackpottery." But both of these behaviors throw the
baby out with the bathwater. Anyone who stumbles across a way (for
example) to extract energy from the Zero Point Fields, will at first
glance
appear to be claiming the existence of perpetual motion. If a
non-scientist, an amateur, discovers an unexpected source of energy, how
can that amateur hope to convince anyone to take their claims seriously?
How can they convince the experts to actually review their evidence?
Their voice will be hidden among the voices of the many crackpots.
Therefore we should take care to never automatically reject all "free
energy" reports before inspecting the evidence.
Also, if such things as "Vacuum Energy converters" may be discovered
someday, there's always the chance that a non-scientist might be the first
to stumble across a way to build a successful device. After all,
professional scientists cannot pursue such things intentionally ( too
damaging to one's career!) If "free energy" devices are easy to build,
then the secret to success might be within the reach of amateurs who
follow up on their anomalous observations. Professional scientists will
tend to ignore any anomaly which violates the conservation of energy.
While it might be correct to say that the discovery of "Free Energy" has
low probability, it is very definitely wrong to dismiss these claims on
the grounds that the probable existence of unknown energy sources is
exactly zero.
On the other hand, "perpetual motion" crackpots really do exist in large
numbers. Nowdays they attempt to hide behind the name "free energy."
How can we sort the lunatic from the maverick heretical scientists? We can
use the same methods science has aways used : take a hard and honest look
at the PHYSICAL EVIDENCE; at the experimental results. It doesn't matter
if a person is a PhD physicist or an unschooled backyard experimenter,
their physical evidence will show if their discovery is real.
Q3: IS THERE A CONSPIRACY TO SUPPRESS THESE DEVICES?A: Yes and no.
Here's an analogy.
Is there a CONSPIRACY to keep women in low-paying jobs? No, there is just
wide-ranging sexism, and the sexist employers need not "conspire"
together.
To the people who are victims of sexist behavior, it may seem as if
employers are conspiring together against them. But bigotry is not a
conspiracy. Instead it is a sort of psychological disease which spreads
through groups of people. We might become "infected" with bigotry, but
obviously no secret organization is needed for bigotry to spread. We
don't have to join a secret society in order to become a practicing
sexist. In other words, suppression usually has nothing to do with
conspiracies. If a woman complains that people in positions of power are
keeping her down, should we accuse her of being a crackpot; a conspiracy
theorist? Obviously not. (And anyone who made such an accusation is
probably a bigot himself.) Similarly, if somebody accuses an inventor of
conspiracy theories ONLY because the inventor complains of suppression,
then it's the accuser who has mental problems; not the inventor.
Prejudice against the "Free Energy" research field is directly analogous
to sexism. There really are people who behave as "science bigots," and
constantly
attack FE adherents. They smear the field with derogatory names and use
fairly underhanded tactics to discredit the research. They counter any
complaints about their behavior with accusations of paranoia. (If you
complain about the hostile actions of scoffers, you must be a conspiracy
theorist?!!! Yeah, riiiight.) And the scoffers believe that their
behavior is proper. They're
convinced that "science" needs to be defended against the Hoards Of
Crackpots. They're convinced that it's a WAR, and in war, any kind of
underhanded tactics become
acceptable. If tomorrow I were to publicly announce that I was attempting
to duplicate some inventor's claimed "overunity device," I would expect to
receive smug laughter and sneering putdowns from most reputable scientists
who chanced to hear about it. If my income depended on peer review by
other scientists, I would expect to have the funding for my
legitimate projects called into question. But this intellectual
suppression is
a result of belief systems, not of conspiracy. Sneering scientists know,
WITHOUT EXAMINING EVIDENCE, that I must be some sort of deranged crackpot.
They take "justified" action in preventing my incompetent waste of
federal funding. But what if they're wrong? The problem is not that
crackpots
might waste funding. The problem is that "crackpots" are condemned
without any fair hearing (usually without any hearing at all.)
Was it a conspiracy which threatened great unconventional discoveries
of the past? The scientists who derided and dismissed plate tectonics,
flying machines, black holes, spacecraft,
television, etc., they didn't belong to any conspiracy. Do the scientists
of today ridicule free energy? Well, history teaches us that ever was it
so. If a new discovery is totally outside of contemporary science, it
will be disparaged by scientists. If it later is proved to be genuine,
the scoffing scientists silently accept it, hope that nobody notices their
earlier sneering, and they might even claim that their disparagement never
happened. History shows many instances of this process. Yet apparently
the lessons of history have no impact on the behavior of these
"suppressors of dissent."
No conspiracy is needed to explain why a widespread group of people will
exhibit identical styles of prejudice and ignorance. Perhaps some genuine
F/E devices might be suppressed, but look to human nature for the cause,
not to secret conspiracies.
On the other hand, a few inventors have reported actual harassment, among
them H. Moray, John Bedini, Floyd Sweet,
Kawai,
Dr. Paul Brown, and Richard Clem. Adam
Trombly had his homopolar machine patent placed under a federal Secrecy
Order. Teuro Kawai's magnetic
motor was taken over by the japanese mafia. Attempts at active
suppression occasionally do occur, but these are not the major force
keeping FE devices off the market. Look to bigotry and the human
need to gather together in groups to ridicule those who do
something new and different.
Q4: AREN'T MOST F/E DEVICES REALLY JUST SCAMS TO RIP OFF GULLIBLE PEOPLE?A: No, most of them are not. But some are. As the skeptics constantly say, "KEEP YOUR HAND ON YOUR WALLET!" :) Don't make donations to companies unless they are registered Nonprofit organizations with all of their finances exposed for inspection. Don't EVER buy expensive device-plans by mail-order. Don't EVER buy a franchise in a free energy sales company until the inventors have broken their secrecy and allowed independent groups to test their devices.
The vast majority of F/E researchers really are honestly pursuing the goal
of New Science which makes "fuelless" portable energy sources possible.
Some have even advanced to the point where they need funds to properly
develop
their discoveries. However, since scams are so very common and widespread
in this field,
investors in F/E companies should be extremely wary. They should expect
to lose their investment, and never risk their life savings. After all,
longshot-betting is risky, even if it sometimes does give large
returns!
It's not hard to detect a scam. Honest companies give full disclosure of
all details so that anyone can successfully duplicate their hardware.
Scammers carefully keep everything secret and unproven. Honest
researchers are only slightly untrustworthy, and they make mistakes.
After all,
they're human. Scammers keep all their mistakes carefully hidden, and
they
inspire your total confidence (that's why it's called a "con game.")
Honest companies
can give you the names of independent researchers and test labs who can
verify that the invention really works. Scammers give you a long list of
very sensible
reasons why the invention is still unproven and/or secret. In
short, if it's secret, if it's "being suppressed by the government," then
it's a scam. Simple.
Some skeptics claim that ALL free energy reports are scams. They are
wrong, and they probably have a hidden reason to be making this claim.
However, the people who claim that NO F/E scams exist are similar:
look for their hidden agenda. The truth is somewhere between. People
who are interested in the truth won't make such confident blanket
declarations about "free energy."
Q5: WHERE CAN I BUY ONE TO POWER MY HOME OR CAR?A: No successful F/E machine exists. The situation resembles that with flying machines in 1900: there are occasional successes, lots of crazy overblown claims, experts smugly assuring us that such things are impossible, crackpots with crazy theories, and megalomaniac inventors hiding fantastic discoveries both real and imagined. There are large prizes waiting for the first person who can demonstrate genuine success. There are also lots of con-artists out there who will let you invest in secretive research companies, or who will sell you as many free energy devices as you can afford! But the equivalent of the "Wright Brothers" have yet to appear on the scene and show us how to REALLY do it right. Nobody yet has won any of the free energy prizes. Drs. Pons and Fleichman came close to "Wright Brothers" status with their cold fusion discovery, but couldn't penetrate the walls of skepticism.Q6: BUT.. BUT.. *PLANS* FOR F/E DEVICES ARE FOR SALE!A: As of 04/2004, no proven F/E device exists. Hundreds of amateurs are hotly pursuing anything which could lead to success. There are several FREE ENERGY PRIZES, but so far nobody has won any of them. The first person to achieve even a fraction of a watt can make "infinite batteries" which never need replacing, and then become the founder of the next Eveready or Duracall corporation. Make no mistake, a free energy device is as valuable (and dangerous) as a method for converting lead into gold.
Yet some mail-order companies sell plans for working free energy devices.
THESE ARE A LIE AND A RIPOFF! The companies pretend that the plans really
work. They don't say "experimental only," or "speculative," or "unproven
device". Some companies even suggest that their devices could power a
home or a car. But they cannot even run a flashlight. Their prices are
high, which might be reasonable if the devices were real. But since they
don't work, the high price is simply a way to maximize the ripoff. If you've been ripped off by one of these "plans" companies, you can lodge a complaint with the Federal Trade Comission in the USA, and if the plans were sent through the US Mail, you can complain about mail fraud (a federal offense, literally.) FTC complaint form Suppose it was 1890 (long before the Wright brothers.) Would you buy plans for a "genuine" flying machine that lets you soar over your friends houses? If so, you'd be the victim of a scammer. Or suppose it was 1930, would you buy plans for a "genuine" atomic generator to run your home? Of course not. Neither would you buy a formula for turning lead into gold, or buy magic pellets that turn water into gasoline. And you'd laugh at anyone who tried to sell you a map to a lost gold mine, since you know that it's a scam. Only a dimwit would fall for such ripoffs. The ripoffs are obviously designed to get money from victims. If the claims were real, then the sellers would be using their discoveries to become wealthy. They wouldn't be messing around with sales of cheap plans to billion-dollar discoveries. In exactly
the same way; you'd
better not pay $80 or even $10 for "real" free energy plans. Think about
it: if
someone
can make a successful FE machine, WHY ARE THEY SELLING PLANS? Why don't
they just build the fully-functional devices and sell them?
Become famous overnight like the
Wright Brothers did?
Simple: since their machines don't work, the FTC would put them in jail
immediately if they sold the fake devices. But if they only sell plans to
the gullible, they can get
away
with it. When a hobbyist builds the device and it does not work, the
seller can BLAME THE HOBBYIST for not doing it right. The hobbyist then
has no proof that the plans could ever work. See, plans are great for
scammers. The feds will go after fradulent products much more fiercely
than they will go after the fradulent booklets of plans. So "vote with
your wallet," and don't send any money to
these dishonest "plans" companies. If you already have wasted money, then
contact the URLs above. Mail-order ripoffs are a federal crime, so it
should be easy to get a very quick refund. Also remember: if nobody
complains to the FTC about dishonest companies, then the scammers can go
on for years without being stopped.
On the other hand, there are a couple of HONEST companies which sell
mail-order booklets and information packets at reasonable prices. They
provide information for amateur researchers. They just quietly provide a
service without all the screaming hype. They NEVER sell expensive secret
plans for "real" gravitational energy generators or fuelless motors which
can run a home or car. For these companies, search Google for Rex
Research and BSRF (Borderlands Science). And check out the large archive
of free information on Keelynet.com
|